May 13 2009
Own It Challenge: Part 2 – The Excuses
In case you missed it, check out Part 1 – The Challenge.
The Poll
First – dudes…take the poll over on the right. And…moving along.
The Team
I hung out with some of my friends last night and a couple girls (Annie and Betsy) pointed out that I gave guys an “out” in yesterday’s post by mentioning that some of us are bench players – that is, we don’t have anyone we’re interested in. Here’s my advice: guys, we shouldn’t just label ourselves a “bench player” by default. This whole challenge is about – well, challenging ourselves! Here are a list of excuses I often make in not asking girls out…and what I’ve learned.
My “I-Don’t-Care-About-Nuance-Or-Thoroughness” Excuse Explosion List
- “I don’t want to be rejected.” I asked a girl out and got turned down a few months ago. She probably didn’t dig me and that’s cool. I’m still breathing! Fellas, girls want dudes who will take risks. At a minimum, that means you have to risk looking like an idiot. You have to risk her saying no.
- “I hardly know her and want to hang in a group to find out what she’s like.” It should only take a few hangs to figure it out. Don’t use this wise practice as a copout. If you’ve hung out 5 times, she uses deodorant semi-regularly, and is still attractive to you, it’s time for a call-up.
- “I have poor social skills and wouldn’t be able to carry a conversation on the date.” Figure out how not to be boring. Make a list of questions to ask her (but don’t read from it on the date!
. And practice YOUR answers to them because she’ll probably shoot your questions back to you to answer. - “I’m afraid of ruining a friendship.” Listen, if things don’t work, you’ll figure it out. If the date makes things weird, it’s only because you rocked the boat a little. After a period of time, things will come back to center.
- “She’s already seeing someone (or one of my friends is already into her).” Either wait it out or move along and get your mind off her. Or, if you’re especially bold, talk to your friend who likes her and tell him to make a move or move out of the way (a little more diplomatically than that).
- “I don’t have enough money to take a girl out.” All it takes is 20-30 bucks! Go donate plasma or bet your friends you’ll eat a whole bag of Totinos Pizza Rolls in an hour. The latter would be profitable both monetarily and delicious-arily.
- “If I ask a girl out, people are going to think I like her. I don’t want other girls to think I’m interested in her.” This is also called “keeping my options open.” In many situations, social pressure can be a deterrent from destructive behavior. Randomly making out with girls in your friend group is a bad idea. That’s good social pressure. But taking a girl out for a meal shouldn’t be in this category. Strange enough, T.I.’s song “Live Your Life” has been a real help to me in this regard. If someone wants to judge you for asking a girl out then let them. Live your life! Don’t be paralyzed by what someone else thinks when the action you’re taking isn’t deceitful or bad. You’re the dude taking control and owning your life. Just because lots of other dudes are “playing it cool” doesn’t mean you have to.
There’s Talent in the System (or… You’re Probably Not a Bench Player)
So here’s my practical suggestion for today. Think you’re a bench player? You’ve got no prospects in your farm system? Don’t be so sure. I thought the same thing. Until I popped Facebook open. Here’s what I did…
- Login to Facebook
- On the left sidebar, you’ll see a link of how many friends you have (mine says 737 friends). Click it (orange arrow)
- On the left bar of this page, click your city or organization. For me, it was Nashville, TN (again, Orange arrow)
- Look through the list of girls you know. And get ready for your temperature to rise. You’ll be scrolling along and quickly dismiss them. “No, no, no, no, no, no, no.” And then you’ll come across a girl you dig. “Oh, crap!” It’s like you’ve just been convicted of robbing a bank. You’re getting hot and your heart is beating faster. You found a girl you wouldn’t mind taking out. Now what to do? You’re not a bench player anymore, homie! You just got put into the game. Time to call her. You’ve got to own it and take the challenge! (P.S. CALL HER! Don’t ask her out through Facebook/Twitter/email/text. I learned this the hard way and I’ll talk about it tomorrow).


1 girl to date.
2 hours to talk.
20 bucks to eat.
Welcome to the big leagues!
And for those of you wondering if I’ve been taking my own advice, the answer is yes. I’ve asked a couple girls out in the past month.
Bros, still skeptical or unsure of exactly how to go about making this a chill date? How to ask her? How to plan these two hours? I’ll write more tomorrow on how to make all that happen!
Now check out Part 3 – The Call.
Plug This!
Feel like adding some banner action on your blog? Check out the stuff below.
![]() |
![]() |







Andy:
I’m an occasional reader of your blog and couldn’t resist posting here. First of all, you’re a fantastic guy and I deeply admire your incredible degree of sincerity and enthusiasm, but I have to admit that this challenge feels like it’s for a younger demographic. And maybe it is! I just know that I have difficulty identifying with it on any level. Then again, I’m in my early 30s (which is perhaps much older than the intended demographic), divorced, and a bit jaded — or perhaps I should say too much of a realist? I wonder if others out there identify with me. Maybe not. At any rate, it would appear that your female readership is loving this, and I do hope you connect with some timid male souls out there who are afraid to take the plunge. Grace and peace to you, and best wishes on your writing endeavors.
Cameron
Well done Andy. Glad to have you back!
Quick thought on excuse #3: A girl might find it endearing in a “Big Bang Theory” kind of way if you read questions off of index cards during the date. I’m just sayin’.
Consider this post retweeted. As soon as I hop over to Twitter I mean.
Laters,
Jenn
Nicely done!
To anyone reading this, Cameron is a friend of mine in Nashville – a great, published writer who blogs here.
Good word here, Cameron. Truly, I don’t expect this to connect with everyone. Some guys already own it. Like you pointed out, I’m mainly writing this to encourage the rest of us not to be so afraid – to be comfortable with more of who we are and what we feel. I know there are lots of dudes who have already reached that point – and I know you’re one of them. You rock, bro! Thanks for the comment!
Andy, I just had to respond to the things your “occasional reader” Cameron said above. I don’t believe what he said was truly “friendly” at all, but a poorly-disguised jab at your enthusiasm and optimism.
Please, Andy, do NOT listen to those who admit they are jaded because of their past experiences to ruin your enthusiasm for doing things right and encouraging other guys to do the same. What Cameron said is NOT realism – it is cynicism and is not helpful to anyone, least of all guys who have good hearts but just don’t know how to get started with asking girls out.
And it is not your job to write a blog that relates to everyone’s experiences, either. If this blog does not relate to Cameron’s life, then I suggest he stop reading it and also stop trying to get others to join in on his cynical view of dating and relationships. No one ever said this blog was supposed to be written for people like him.
We have all been hurt in some way or another by the opposite sex, but that does not mean we should take it out on each other and project the bad qualities we found in certain individuals onto all the other members of that sex just to make ourselves feel superior. Whatever has made Cameron so jaded needs to make him step back and think about how he can learn from it, move on, and let go of the hurt.
Just because not many guys are responding to this blog challenge doesn’t mean that it’s not a good idea. It IS a good idea, and I think guys aren’t responding to it because they’re still afraid, or, like Cameron, still bitter about something from their past.
My advice to those guys is to seek healing from God and to do what we can to make steps in the right direction. If you guys are not ready for a relationship, fine. But don’t try to discourage guys who are. And if you ARE ready… well, all you have to do is ask Andy to help you meet one of the 100s of amazing girls who are reading his blog and waiting around for you. As you may have noticed, every girl who has taken this survey wants to be asked out.
Just do it!
No idea how I missed this, I’m going back through it now. So my question: Did you take your own advice?